Understanding Judicial Review in Migration Matters

When a visa application is refused, or a visa is cancelled by the Department of Home Affairs, and a subsequent application for merits review before the Administrative Review Tribunal (ART) is not successful, people often ask whether they can “appeal to the court” and as a final resort to getting their preferred outcome.

This is a common misconception. Judicial review is not a continuation of the merits review process, nor is it a second opportunity to present the same arguments in the hope of securing a different outcome.

A recent Federal Court decision, ZSJ v Minister for Immigration and Multicultural Affairs [2026] FCA 1280, demonstrates why this distinction is important. Although the applicant pursued judicial review proceedings on multiple occasions and was successful in his first two attempts, the Court ultimately found no legal error in the ART’s reasoning in the final merits review decision. Despite two successful applications for judicial review following errors in the first two merits review decisions, the applicant’s ultimate outcome remained unchanged because judicial review focuses on legality, not the merits of a decision.

Judicial review does not permit the Court to reassess your personal circumstances, determine whether a decision was fair, or decide whether you should receive a visa. Courts cannot grant visas.

Instead, judicial review is concerned with whether the decision-maker, usually a delegate of the Minister or a Member of the ART, acted according to law. The court does not decide whether the decision was “fair” or whether you “deserve” the visa. It is limited to determining whether a legal error has been made in the decision-making process.

What Is Judicial Review?

Judicial review is the court’s examination of the legality of a migration decision. The court considers:

  • Did the decision-maker apply the law correctly?
  • Did they act within the limits of their legal authority?
  • Did they commit a jurisdictional error?

A jurisdictional error occurs when a decision-maker exceeds their legal authority or fails to exercise those powers in accordance with the law. Put simply, it arises when the decision-maker steps outside the legal framework governing the decision.

Common examples include:

  • Identifying the wrong issue or applying the wrong legal test
  • Ignoring relevant evidence or relying on irrelevant material
  • Failing to consider claims properly raised by an applicant
  • Breaching natural justice (procedural fairness)
  • Failing to follow mandatory procedures
  • Actual or apprehended bias
  • Reaching conclusions that are legally Illogical, irrational, or unreasonable

If a jurisdictional error is established, the court can remit the decision to the ART for redetermination. Importantly, the court does not grant the visa.

Strict time limits apply for judicial review. Applications must be filed correctly, accompanied by the required documents and filing fees. While registered migration agents may assist throughout visa and merits review processes, they cannot represent clients in court proceedings. Applicants seeking representation in judicial review proceedings will therefore require a legal practitioner.

Judicial Review Is Not Merits Review

A critical distinction between merits review and judicial review is the role performed by the decision-maker.

The ART conducts merits review. It examines the evidence and circumstances of the case and determines what the correct or preferable decision should be.

Courts perform an entirely different function. They do not:

  • re-weigh evidence
  • consider your personal circumstances
  • decide whether you should receive a visa

Their role is limited to determining whether the decision was made lawfully. Even where an applicant succeeds in judicial review proceedings, that success results in another opportunity for the matter to be reconsidered by the ART. On the contrary, an unsuccessful applicant may face significant legal costs.

A Recent Example: Why Judicial Review Does Not Guarantee Success

A recent Federal Court decision, VZSJ v Minister for Immigration and Multicultural Affairs [2026] FCA 1280, provides a useful example of these principles.

The applicant, a long-term resident, had his visa mandatorily cancelled under s 501(3A) of the Migration Act 1958 in January 2020 following serious criminal convictions. He argued before the ART that the facts of his domestic violence offence differed from those recorded by the sentencing court. The ART rejected this attempt to consider facts contrary to those before the sentencing courts, and affirmed the cancellation.

In a merits review of this nature, the Tribunal is generally required to proceed on the basis of the fact of conviction and the findings of the sentencing court. It is not empowered to revisit guilt or make findings inconsistent with the conviction and sentence imposed. Its task is to assess the migration consequences arising from those convictions.

The applicant in this case subsequently applied for judicial review, claiming the ART’s reasoning was illogical and legally unreasonable.

The Federal Court disagreed. The Court observed:

“The Tribunal’s findings concerning the facts of the family violence offences were open to it on the material available to it.” and,

“The Tribunal did not ignore or overlook any of the applicant’s case and its reasoning was not illogical or otherwise legally unreasonable.”

The Court found no jurisdictional error had been established on his third attempt at judicial review. Although the applicant disagreed with the ART’s assessment of the evidence, that disagreement did not give rise to a legal error warranting judicial intervention.

Ultimately, following approximately six years of merits review and litigation after original visa cancellation, including two prior successful judicial review attempts, the application was dismissed, and the applicant was ordered to pay costs.

This case demonstrates that judicial review is not a second chance to argue the merits of a migration decision. It also highlights that even a successful judicial review outcome does not necessarily result in a different substantive decision, as the ART may still reach the same conclusion when reconsidering the matter according to the law.

Key Takeaways for Migrants

  • Judicial review concerns legal error, not fairness or personal circumstances.
  • Courts cannot grant visas – a positive outcome allows the court only to set aside an unlawful decision and remit the matter for reconsideration.
  • Strict filing requirements and time limits apply.
  • Costs can be significant if unsuccessful.
  • Registered migration agents cannot represent applicants in court proceedings.
  • Judicial review can be an important safeguard against unlawful decision-making, however a genuine jurisdictional error must be established.

Judicial review plays a vital role in ensuring that migration decisions are made according to law. However, it is not an avenue for re-arguing the facts, introducing new evidence, or seeking a more favourable outcome simply because an applicant disagrees with the decision. Before commencing judicial review proceedings, it is essential to understand the limited nature of the court’s role and obtain advice as to whether an arguable jurisdictional error exists. A carefully assessed case has a far greater prospect of success than one based solely on disagreement with the result.

If you are considering judicial review of a migration decision, obtaining legal advice at an early stage is important to assess whether a jurisdictional error may exist and to ensure any applicable time limits are met. Contact our office for tailored advice regarding your circumstances and available options.

Shadi Golchin, Senior Associate, Immigration, Stone Group Lawyers

About the author

Shadi Golchin

Senior Associate | Immigration

Shadi is a Senior Associate at Stone Group Lawyers, handling the firm’s migration law matters. With extensive experience in navigating Australia’s complex immigration system, she has worked exclusively in migration law since 2016. In her own time, she is also a Sessional Academic in the Graduate Diploma in Australian Migration Law and Practice at Australian Catholic University.

Read more about Shadi